Before You Use a Nipple Shield, Please Ask This Question

You've just had your baby.

You're exhausted, a little overwhelmed, and trying to figure out this whole breastfeeding thing.

But your baby isn't latching quite right. Maybe they keep slipping off the breast. Maybe your nipples are already feeling sore. Maybe you're starting to wonder if you're doing something wrong.

A nurse comes in to help. She watches you try to latch your baby, adjusts a few things, and then says, “Let's try a nipple shield.”

She hands you a little piece of silicone, shows you how to put it on, and suddenly your baby is latching!

Relief. Finally, something is working.

Except…has anyone actually figured out why your baby was struggling to latch in the first place?

Has anyone watched an entire feeding? Evaluated your baby's positioning, how they're attaching to the breast, or whether they're effectively transferring milk?

Or have we just put a Band-Aid on a problem we haven't taken the time to understand?

Nipple shields aren't nearly as harmless as they're often made out to be.

I see them recommended in the hospital far more casually than I'm comfortable with. Sometimes, in the rush to get a baby feeding, we reach for a tool before we've really understood the problem.

And when that tool comes with potential consequences for breastfeeding confidence, milk supply, and long-term breastfeeding success, I think we need to be asking a whole lot more questions.

Nipple Shields Aren't as Harmless as They're Often Made Out to Be

I want to be clear: I'm not saying nipple shields should never be used.

There are circumstances where they can be a helpful tool, particularly for certain babies who are having difficulty transferring milk because of a cleft palate (but not always!).

But the research makes it clear that their use should be the exception, not the default. And they certainly shouldn't be the first thing we reach for when breastfeeding isn't going smoothly.

A 2014 study of nearly 1,500 preterm infants found that nipple shield use was associated with 2.3 times the odds of not exclusively breastfeeding at hospital discharge.

Another study involving more than 4,800 mothers found that nipple shield use was associated with earlier cessation of exclusive breastfeeding, particularly among mothers who continued using shields throughout their breastfeeding journey.

And an ethnographic study examining nipple shield use in neonatal units found that while shields sometimes helped families through difficult periods, they could also become a barrier between parent and baby, affecting confidence and creating dependence on the device.

These studies don't prove that nipple shields cause breastfeeding to end early. But they absolutely give us reason to question how casually they're recommended.


But What About Sore Nipples?

This is one of the most common reasons I see nipple shields recommended, and it's also one of the most frustrating!

A nipple shield doesn't tell us WHY breastfeeding hurts.

Is baby positioned poorly? Is the latch too shallow? Is something interfering with effective milk transfer? Is there an underlying issue that needs further evaluation?

If we haven't answered those questions, what exactly are we treating?

Research hasn't established nipple shields as an effective treatment for sore or damaged nipples. And while they may provide temporary relief for some parents, that doesn't mean we've addressed what's causing the pain.

There's also the question of milk supply.

Effective milk removal and nipple stimulation are important parts of maintaining milk production. A shield can change how the nipple stretches and responds during feeding, and in some circumstances may interfere with milk transfer and stimulation.

That's not something I think we should dismiss, particularly in the earliest days when milk production is being established.

And then there's the practical reality that some families find it surprisingly difficult to transition away from a shield once their baby has become accustomed to using one.

A temporary solution can become a long-term complication if nobody has a plan for what comes next.


Please, Can We Actually Evaluate the Breastfeeding Relationship First?

In my experience, nipple shields are sometimes recommended because the person helping simply doesn't have the time or the knowledge to properly evaluate the breastfeeding relationship.

And I get it. Hospital staff are busy. They're managing competing demands, and many are doing their absolute best with the resources they have. And if we’re being completely honest, some staff with all the right letters after their name did their training years ago and haven’t kept up with best practices as recommendations change.

A parent who's struggling to breastfeed deserves more than a quick fix and a piece of silicone.

They deserve someone who will sit with them, watch an entire feeding, evaluate positioning and latch, assess whether baby is transferring milk effectively, and help identify what's actually going wrong.

Not just make the immediate problem disappear long enough to move on to the next patient.

And if a nipple shield really is the most appropriate option? Great. Let's explain why, make sure baby is getting enough milk, monitor supply, and develop a plan to reassess whether it's still needed.


If Someone Recommends a Nipple Shield, Ask Questions

If you're offered a nipple shield, I want you to know that you can ask:

  • Why do you think my baby needs this?

  • Have we fully evaluated positioning, latch, and milk transfer?

  • What else could we try first?

  • How will we know whether baby is getting enough milk with the shield?

  • What's our plan for follow-up and eventually transitioning away from it?

And if you're not getting answers, please seek help from someone who can provide a thorough breastfeeding assessment when you're experiencing persistent pain, latch difficulties, or concerns about milk transfer.

You deserve to understand what's happening, not just be handed another thing to manage.

And if you're already using a nipple shield? This isn't a reason to panic or feel like you've done something wrong. If it's helping you feed your baby, don't abruptly stop using it without making sure your baby can feed effectively without it.

Just know that you're allowed to ask whether you still need it, and to get support figuring that out.

The goal isn't simply to get a baby latched for the next feeding.

It's to help you and your baby establish a breastfeeding relationship that actually works for both of you.

And that deserves a whole lot more attention than a piece of silicone.


Breastfeeding Shouldn't Be Something You Have to Figure Out Alone

If breastfeeding is painful, your baby is struggling to latch, or you're getting conflicting advice and aren't sure what to try next, let's figure out what's actually going on.

I offer two ways to get hands-on, individualized breastfeeding:

Free Breastfeeding Drop-In Hour (Grinnell and Des Moines

Stop by on Wednesdays from 3:30–4:30 p.m. to ask questions, check your baby's latch, or troubleshoot those little challenges before they become bigger frustrations. No appointment needed!

Private Lactation Sessions

Need more time and individualized attention? We can work together to explore positioning, latch, feeding patterns, and practical strategies that work for you and your baby, with referrals for more specialized care when needed.


You deserve more than a quick fix. You deserve to understand what's happening and feel confident feeding your baby.

References

  1. Maastrup R, et al. (2014). Factors Associated with Exclusive Breastfeeding of Preterm Infants: Results from a Prospective National Cohort Study. PLOS ONE, 9(2), e89077.

  2. Kronborg H, Foverskov E, Nilsson I, Maastrup R. (2017). Why Do Mothers Use Nipple Shields and How Does This Influence Duration of Exclusive Breastfeeding?. Maternal & Child Nutrition, 13(1), e12251.

  3. Flacking R, Dykes F. (2017). Perceptions and Experiences of Using a Nipple Shield Among Parents and Staff—An Ethnographic Study in Neonatal Units. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 17, 1.

Elise Hall

Elise Hall is a full spectrum doula, perinatal corrective exercise specialist, and certified babywearing educator. She loves teaching yoga, barre, and pilates, homeschooling her two kids, and playing with her dogs Sunny and Bandit.

https://www.elisehalldoula.com
Next
Next

Hands off! How to actually get a good latch with your newborn